Christian Empathy: Where is it?
My friend Joe, an agnostic Christian, and I had a nice chat on the phone last night. We had not seen each other over the Holidays and were discussing our Xmas family experiences. During the course of our conversation, he relayed an incident which happened at a soup kitchen that his church sponsored.
It seems that one of Joe's church friends has recently 'gotten the spirit' and become a very vocal evangelical. Joe attends a rather liberal Methodist church - extremely liberal for our area - and there aren't many holy warriors who are his fellow parishioners. During the soup kitchen, a young Guatemalan family entered; a dad, mom and two young children. Joe and his newly Jesus’ed up friend walked forward to welcome them. Joe attempted to welcome them in Spanish and make them feel at home. Joe's evangelical friend immediately bent down one of the kids and said, "Hi, do you know Jesus?"
Joe said that he simply walked away in disbelief but now wishes he had said something immediately to his friend. To his credit, Joe is going to tell his friend that he thinks that his actions were completely inappropriate in that setting - a soup kitchen. Joe raised the point that his friend evidently cannot imagine what it would be like to have someone push their religion on you in those circumstances. In other words, his friend cannot empathize. I laughed and told Joe that I had met very few Christians who seem capable of empathy with people of other faiths or non-believers.
If you examinethe major conflicts between the secular world and religion, in the
Is it really so hard for Christians to, for one second, imagine if they were the minority and it was the beliefs and rituals of someone else that were constantly promoted and sometimes forced upon them? Do Christians simply not care? Is it a 'evangelize at any cost' mentality that governs? Is it simply the nature of a majority to behave in a manner akin to fascism?
I have to say that the vast majority of Christians I know have a major failing when it comes to having empathy for those of differing religions. Most of them have zero empathy for those with no religious beliefs. Perhaps Christians love playing the victim so much that possessing or demonstrating empathy is simply contrary to the role. I really don't know. My thinking now is so far away from that narrow, dark and frightened place that ruled it when I was a believer that trying to decipher the motivations of the faithful now is almost impossible for me.
By the way, when the 'war on Christmas' is over, will someone tell me?
Tagged as:'war on christmas',christian,atheist,atheism,religion



9 Comments:
Re: the war on Xmas...
MISSION ACCOMPLISHED
(Well, as you've noticed, there's been no mention of the holiday in the media, national or local, in the last week or so...)
I think that you are basically right, but to be honest,I think that all members/believers of a monotheistic religion lack empathy. Their whole religion is actually based on this principle. If they would show or have empathy for other religious beliefs their own religion couldn´t be the onlyone anymore.
And this principle is in my opionion one of the main reasons for all the "unpleasentness" we have in the world, especially religious driven terrorism and war (muslim, christian and jewish).
Dale,
What ever you do, BTW, I hope the both of you have a great "06" and hopefully, Barbara and I will see you guys "on the circuit" soon. Why I am writing is to tell you to spread the word on the book: Don't Know Much About Mythology.
As an atheist, it is a very difficult thing to understand that a believer hasn't ever "imagined" (as Lennon pointed out) but, most haven't. I grew up Catholic and can remember back to the nature of my ignorance. It was just that- it was ignorance of anything non-catholic. In effect, it was brainwashing for that is their main tool of business. If you could get past the mistaken notion that that you somehow follow Satan, you might get a sliver of an idea past the concrete wall of righteousness.
Hi Alan,
Just meandered over to your blog from Don's. What a great post. The Soup Kitchen experience you relate calls into question that whole "faith-based" human services trend. On one hand, having come out of the social services sector, I realize that in urban centers, the places most folks go for food, daycare, and other services are the churches in their 'hood. So I can see the logic of directing funding into qualified programs. On the other hand, what about crap like that which you describe?
I'm what you'd call a recovering catholic. All of the mystery of the rituals of the church that once seemed so beautiful to me, that once made me feel that religion was a very personal experience, have been hijacked by the Charismatics and discarded in favor of this neurotic evangelical trend. The more I witness this, the more convinced I am than ever that religion is merely another dangerous tool to exert control over different groups, cultures, and classes. It's been that way since before the Crusades, and it will never change.
I look forward to visiting often and reading more.
All of the "Chistmas is too commercial", and "Put Christ back in Christmas", and "Give us back our Pagan holiday!", and "It's not really Ye-Shua's birthday!" arguments have been wrapped up and put away with the mistletoe, and glass ornaments, and light-up Rudolphs and plastic tannenbaums until next year, as they have been since Edison invented the light-up Rudolph, and before.
As for Christian empathy, the hypnotized will only show empathy if the hypnotist tells them to.
The War on Christmas was won by atheists 150 years ago. Christians are just jealous of our holiday and tring to retake it, like they do to any other holiday that is not "theirs". They are sacrilegous thieves and have always been. Then again, what do you expect from a religion based on control and lies ?
Mando Mama Said,
The Soup Kitchen experience you relate calls into question that whole "faith-based" human services trend.
Yes, it is situations like this which are all to familiar to anyone who has ever taken advantage of faith-based help programs, that convinces me that the programs should be stopped. These programs are already funded with tax-exempt donations to the churches anyway.
This post has been removed by a blog administrator.
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home